Nathan's post | Quora

Is SJM Stock the Underdog of My Portfolio? My Honest Thoughts After Holding for 2 Years Okay, let’s get real for a second. SJM stock—yes, The J. M. Smucker Company, the peanut butter and jelly people—was NOT on my radar for the longest time. I used to think of them as that sleepy grocery store brand my grandma loved. But about two years ago, I took a chance and added SJM to my portfolio. Why? Stability, baby. But let me tell you, the story didn’t go exactly how I imagined! The Allure of Comfort Stocks Back in 2022, everything felt wobbly. Tech stocks were wild, crypto was a rollercoaster, and honestly, I just wanted a little financial “comfort food.” SJM stock, with its long history (like, 125 years old!) and those classic brands, seemed like the steady choice. When you bite into a PB&J, you’re not expecting surprises, right? That was my logic with Smucker. But here’s the thing—SJM isn’t just about jelly anymore. They’ve quietly scooped up some huge brands: Folgers coffee, Jif, Milk-Bone (hello, dog parents!) and even picked up Hostess Brands recently. That’s a full-on snack empire! I thought, “Hey, people eat snacks during good times and bad. Maybe this is my anchor stock.” Rollercoaster Reality: My SJM Experience Fast-forward to now, and my SJM shares haven’t exactly been fireworks. The price has been…let’s say, “cozy.” Not a lot of sizzle. When I check my portfolio, SJM sits there like a reliable but quiet roommate. The dividends are nice—honestly, getting that quarterly payout feels like finding an extra coffee at the back of the fridge. But the share price? It’s mostly shuffled sideways, with a few dips that made me side-eye my decision. I’ve seen SJM get heat online for being “boring.” Some folks even call it a “boomer stock.” And yeah, it’s not gonna 10x overnight. But boring isn’t always bad! When the market tanks, SJM is one of those stocks that doesn’t freak out. It’s like the friend who brings snacks to the party when everyone else is losing their minds. But…Is SJM Worth Holding? Here’s where my feelings get mixed. On one hand, SJM’s brands are everywhere. Coffee, snacks, dog treats—these are staples. The Hostess buyout was a curveball, and honestly, I’m still watching to see if that pays off (Twinkies in the Smucker family is wild to me). But there are real worries, too. Grocery inflation is squeezing margins, and consumer trends move FAST. Those fancy new snack brands you see on TikTok? They eat into legacy brands like Smucker’s. Plus, SJM’s debt ticked up after the Hostess deal—so I’m keeping an eye on that. I don’t want my comfort stock turning into a liability! My Takeaway (and a Little Advice) So, would I buy more SJM right now? To be real, it’s not my most exciting pick. But I’m not selling, either. I like having a few steady stocks that quietly do their job, even if they don’t make headlines. If you’re looking for a thrill ride, SJM probably isn’t it. But if you want some stability and a little dividend love, it’s worth a look. My advice? Don’t sleep on the “boring” stocks. Sometimes they’re the ones keeping your portfolio steady when everything else is chaos. And if you’re a fellow SJM holder, let me know—do you see it as a future star, or just a trusty sidekick? Drop your thoughts below, I want to hear your takes! TL;DR: SJM stock isn’t flashy, but it’s got a place in my portfolio. Sometimes you need a PB&J in a world obsessed with avocado toast. Would love to hear what YOU think!