If you're trying to figure out what gear you need for AT&T Fiber, here's the gist: AT&T provides you with a combined modem/router device (they call it a "Gateway") when you sign up, and yes, there's usually a monthly fee unless you negotiate otherwise. If you're a tinkerer or care about Wi-Fi performance, you might want your own router, but you can't skip their box entirely. Below, I’ll share the headaches, the gotchas, and everything I wish I’d known before the installer showed up at my door.
So, picture this: I finally get AT&T Fiber installed in my place after months of spotty cable internet. I’m expecting blazing speeds, but before I can even connect, the installer plunks down a big white box (the infamous "Gateway") and hands me a bunch of cables. I instantly wonder: do I need my own router? Is this box my modem and router? Are they going to charge me for this thing? Turns out, this is a super common question, and the answer is a bit messy.
AT&T Fiber doesn't use a traditional cable modem. Instead, it relies on an ONT (Optical Network Terminal) which converts the fiber optic signal to something your network can use. But—and here's where it gets confusing—most residential installs include a single "Gateway" device that acts as both the modem (handling the ONT function) and the router. Sometimes, the ONT is a separate box; sometimes, it's built into the Gateway.
Officially, AT&T requires you to use their supplied Gateway (for example, models like the BGW210, BGW320, or Pace 5268AC). This is non-negotiable for residential plans—no way to skip it entirely. If you want to use your own router for advanced Wi-Fi, you can, but the AT&T Gateway has to stay in the setup (usually in "passthrough" or "bridge" mode).
Here's where things get spicy. Unlike with cable providers, you cannot use your own modem or skip AT&T's Gateway entirely. But you can add your own router behind theirs, which is what I did for better Wi-Fi coverage. Here’s what I did:
192.168.1.254
in my browser.Small warning: If you mess up the IP Passthrough setup, you might end up with double NAT issues (your devices can’t talk to the outside world correctly). I did this on my first attempt and had to reset everything. If you want the step-by-step, there’s a great Reddit thread with screenshots: r/ATT: BGW320 IP Passthrough Mode.
AT&T is pretty strict about the $10/month equipment fee (see AT&T's fee policy). If you want to use their optional mesh Wi-Fi extenders, that's another $10/month. There's no way to supply your own ONT or Gateway; the hardware is registered to your account. If you lose or damage the Gateway, there’s a non-return fee (up to $150) per their official support.
One fun fact I learned: If you upgrade your plan and need a new Gateway (for example, to get Wi-Fi 6 or higher speeds), AT&T will ship you a new one and expect you to return the old one. If you don't, the fee applies.
For those who care about international trade or want to see how US telecom equipment rules compare globally, here's a quick table with "verified trade" certification standards across countries. I pulled this from OECD and US Trade Representative docs (USTR, OECD).
Country | Standard Name | Legal Reference | Enforcement Body |
---|---|---|---|
USA | Verified Internet Equipment List | FCC 47 CFR Part 68 | Federal Communications Commission (FCC) |
EU | CE Marking and RED Directive | Directive 2014/53/EU | European Commission, National Telecom Agencies |
Japan | Technical Standards Conformity Certification | Telecommunications Business Law | Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications |
China | Network Access License (NAL) | MIIT Order No. 11 | Ministry of Industry and Information Technology |
You can see that the US is super strict about certified equipment (FCC rules), which is why AT&T insists you use their approved Gateway. In the EU, you could, in theory, use your own router if it meets CE and RED requirements, which is why some European ISPs are more flexible than AT&T. For more, see the OECD's Broadband Policy Toolkit (PDF).
Back in 2022, a friend in Germany switched to Deutsche Telekom's fiber and immediately bought his own Fritz!Box router. No rental, no drama—the ISP just gave him the credentials. Compare that to the US, where (as confirmed by an AT&T rep I spoke with during my setup), "All customer premises equipment must be supplied by AT&T for Fiber, as required by internal authentication and FCC regulations."
Industry expert Dr. Simone Wu (quoted in the WTO Aid for Trade report, p. 77) notes: "The ability for consumers to supply their own equipment is more common in Europe, due to the implementation of open access and harmonized standards, whereas US providers often cite security and service assurance as reasons to restrict CPE choice."
In practice, this means AT&T customers are locked into their Gateway, while users in many OECD countries have more choice (and potentially lower costs).
To sum up: AT&T Fiber requires their Gateway device, which you can’t avoid—including the $10/month fee. If you care about Wi-Fi performance, plan to add your own router, but the Gateway will always be in the mix. You can't buy your own ONT or substitute your own modem the way you can with some cable providers. Compared to other countries, US rules are stricter—mostly because of FCC certification and AT&T's authentication systems.
If you’re researching before your install, my advice is: clear a spot for the Gateway near your ONT or fiber drop, have an Ethernet cable ready for your own router if you want to use one, and don’t expect to dodge the equipment fee. If you’re moving from Europe or Asia, prepare for less flexibility. For more details, check the official AT&T Equipment FAQ and the FCC’s broadband rules.
If you hit a snag (or just want to see people vent their frustrations), the AT&T forums and Reddit threads are full of folks who’ve been there. And if you figure out a way to skip the equipment fee, I’d love to hear about it—because after years of paying it, I still haven’t found a loophole.